Big Pink reviewed in the Independent on Sunday

Steve Jelbert (who was, under a previous regime, contracted to write a book for us at Continuum) reviews John Niven’s Big Pink book in the Independent on Sunday today. I’m tempted to put “gloriously absurd” on the back cover, when we reprint.


Music From Big Pink by John Niven
By Steve

The Band’s 1968 debut album Music From Big Pink is the veritable Ur-text of Rock Snobbery, an artefact so definitive only the brave and deluded would even approach it (and they did). It inspired Greil Marcus – if not the Dean of Rock certainly a man with a wood-panelled office – to write Mystery Train, his first and maybe finest tome. This set of songs, cooked up in a rented house in bucolic Woodstock, New York, during breaks from their regular employer Bob Dylan, landed in the Swinging Sixties like a time capsule unearthed from the previous century. It was taupe in a Technicolor age, organic not synthetic, inhabited by the ghosts of an America which predated sound recording.

It was also fake, a work of smart artifice. Drummer Levon Helm apart, the Band were Canadian lads healthily fixated on songs previously presumed lost, and unearthed by archivists like Harry Smith and Alan Lomax. Although they toyed with names like the Crackers (way off the mark) or the more accurate Honkies, their drab monicker captured perfectly their undeniable precision. Dylan’s first movie might have been called Don’t Look Back, but his backing musicians started the trend for nostalgia. There’s an argument that American rock music has yet to recover from 1968. Its dress sense certainly hasn’t.

But writing anything new about this lovable cultural millstone is problematic. So as his contribution to Continuum’s well-received 33 1/3 series of little books on big albums, John Niven has penned a novella inspired by the era’s events. The narrator, Greg Keltner, a none-too-bright Canadian drug-dealer, moves in high and low places. He scores in the city then services the musicians of Woodstock, as the anonymous town chosen by Dylan as a bolthole rapidly becomes a hippy mecca. The temporarily connected Greg sneers at the rubes and hangs out with a cast of characters that includes an entire line-up of Sixties stars, a few of them still with us.

It’s a great gimmick. Passing celebs such as a taciturn Dylan, his creepily controlling manager Albert Grossman, and a hilarious, speed-addled Lou Reed, conform to every biographical description of them ever printed. Boon companions include the party-hearty bassist Rick Danko and the unfortunate Richard Manuel, whose quavering voice anchored the Band’s best music and whose 1986 suicide opens the book, setting obese junkie Greg to reminiscing. Robbie Robertson, Band leader and guitarist, is described merely as cold, ie in control. (It took Hollywood to bring him low, according to Peter Biskind’s Easy Riders, Raging Bulls.)

Niven is no stylist, though. Although he certainly knows how musicians talk – he worked in the record business for years – there are some stilted conversations captured here. (Being kind, he may just be mocking the meetings of the starstruck and the talent.) The obligatory femme fatale, about as convincing as one of Dylan’s idealised subjects, even bears the gloriously absurd name Skye Grey. Greg’s florid attempts to describe events of years past make this a strong argument against the use of narcotics, but they’re hard to read without squirming.

The schematic structure of the book, each incident ticked off as the narrative moves forward, is surely more obvious than the author intended, and interferes with a convincing description of an aimless life. A melodramatic funeral scene stretches the reader’s credulity and the use of historical events to delineate time is corny at best. (Did regional television stations really hold a vigil for Andy Warhol after his shooting by Valerie Solanas? I doubt it.)

But there are compensations. The narrative drive is irresistible, while set-pieces such as a night tripping at the flicks with a chick, or eviction from a party on Dylan’s orders, convey public embarrassment (or its absence) beautifully. All such analyses of individual records are exercises in nostalgia to some extent, so why shouldn’t the shaky voice of a fitfully imagined middle-aged man with no future and only hazy memories of a worthwhile past represent them all? This may be no more than the literary equivalent of a promising demo tape, but it is certainly distinct. Well done to Niven for giving a voice to the sleazy foot soldiers of rock’n’roll. They also serve who stand on weight.

1 thought on “Big Pink reviewed in the Independent on Sunday”

  1. I wonder when Steve Jelbert heard “Music from Big Pink” anyway? You should have heard it in 68, son, and spared us the revisionism. As far as being “fake” – that’s a lot of bullshit; Canadian or not, all members of the Band spent eight years honing their craft playing roadhouses and honky-tonks throughout the US, playing with Ronnie Hawkins and Dylan. Levon Helm grew up watching Sonny Boy Williamson play IN PERSON. And since we’re casting dispersions, what would a Brit know about it anyway? ALL of your music is derivative of the American pop scene. Does that mean Eric Claption is a “fake” for playing the blues or the Beatles were “fake” for copying Chuck Berry and Buddy Holly? For my two cents worth, the Band stands at top of the heap more than 30 years later for their stunning fusion of AMERICAN musical styles in their own unique footprint, one that left an enormous impression on the musical landscape.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top